People are saying that book 5 (which I have not yet read) is terrible. I cant imagine how after reading this book. I think it was amazing! the way that RA Salvatore descrobed Ivan and Pikel was phenominal. I fell in love with the two dwarfs and I can't wait to read IN SYLVAN SHADOWS. I have read many fantasy novels such as Elminster in Myth Drannor and Shannara series. With all the books I have read this is by far the best ever. I cant wait to continue the series so try this book out at least!