Kundenrezensionen


 
 
Durchschnittliche Kundenbewertung
Sagen Sie Ihre Meinung zu diesem Artikel
Eigene Rezension erstellen
 
 

Die hilfreichste positive Rezension
Die hilfreichste kritische Rezension


8 von 8 Kunden fanden die folgende Rezension hilfreich
5.0 von 5 Sternen Things are not as they seem. Skim milk masquerades as cream.
Alternate history...Philip K. Dick style.
What does that mean? Well, basically, if you think that the characters in this book seem a little out of place, keep reading, and you may find YOURSELF out of place.
On the surface, it is the usual time-shifting novel...FDR was assasinated in 1936, and as a result, the United States lost WW II. Twenty years in the...
Am 26. Januar 1998 veröffentlicht

versus
3 von 3 Kunden fanden die folgende Rezension hilfreich
3.0 von 5 Sternen Visionäre Grundidee. Die Umsetzung jedoch, kann nicht überzeugen
Was wäre, wenn Roosevelt 1933 nicht erschossen worden wäre? Hätte der Zweite Weltkrieg dann vor 1947 geendet und hätten vielleicht die Achsenmächte und nicht Deutschland und Japan den Krieg gewonnen und die Welt unter sich aufgeteilt? Diese Frage stellt sich der Autor Hawthorne Abendsen in seinem Roman 'The grasshopper lies heay', der in Festung...
Veröffentlicht am 5. Juli 2012 von callisto


‹ Zurück | 1 27 | Weiter ›
Hilfreichste Bewertungen zuerst | Neueste Bewertungen zuerst

8 von 8 Kunden fanden die folgende Rezension hilfreich
5.0 von 5 Sternen Things are not as they seem. Skim milk masquerades as cream., 26. Januar 1998
Von Ein Kunde
Rezension bezieht sich auf: The Man in the High Castle (Vintage) (Taschenbuch)
Alternate history...Philip K. Dick style.
What does that mean? Well, basically, if you think that the characters in this book seem a little out of place, keep reading, and you may find YOURSELF out of place.
On the surface, it is the usual time-shifting novel...FDR was assasinated in 1936, and as a result, the United States lost WW II. Twenty years in the future, when the novel takes place, Nazi Germany and the Japanese Empire have occupied the United States and imposed their brand of culture on their respective halves of the American populace.
But this book really isn't about alternate time lines...its about alternate realities. Things are not as they seem...characters' true identities are hidden, and their moralities are tested. It's about the nature of the true state of the universe, Eastern religion, and the I-Ching. When Philip K. Dick is at his best, his characters question their own existence, and it soon follows that the readers do the same.
So when you come to the end of the book, hopefully, a number of things will happen:
Number 1: You'll instantly re-read the ending.
Number 2: You'll throw the book against the wall and exclaim "that's it?"
Number 3: You'll probably re-read the ending again.
Number 4: You'll swear that you'll never read another Philip K. Dick novel.
Number 5: Later, you'll think a bit about the book, and realize that the novel wasn't really about what you thought it was.
Number 6: You'll read it again. And again...
This isn't your typical sci-fi novel. The story doesn't wrap-up into a neat little package. Like Eastern religions, time is not linear, it is circular, and that is the reality of the book.
Alternate histories are so commonplace in sci-fi today, that it is important to look at this book as the one that really started it all. A completely original masterpiece...even the followers can't keep up.
Helfen Sie anderen Kunden bei der Suche nach den hilfreichsten Rezensionen 
War diese Rezension für Sie hilfreich? Ja Nein


5 von 5 Kunden fanden die folgende Rezension hilfreich
5.0 von 5 Sternen Was für ein Buch!, 8. April 2015
Von 
Ralf Raths "Raths" (Hannover) - Alle meine Rezensionen ansehen
(REAL NAME)   
Verifizierter Kauf(Was ist das?)
Eine Welt, in der die Nazis und die Japaner die Welt unter sich aufgeteilt haben, ist als Setting erstmal ganz spannend, aber nun auch nicht SO originell. Dicks „The Man in the High Castle“ holt aber erstens viel aus der Idee raus und ist zweitens aus eigenem Recht und unabhängig vom Setting große Literatur.

Der erste Punkt ist dabei verblüffend gut gelungen. Das Buch baut eine überzeugende Welt deshalb, weil alles, was beschrieben ist, aus unglaublich präziser Beobachtung extrapoliert wurde. Die Charakterisierungen des NS als Idee und System, die Dick seinen Figuren in den Mund legt, sind sogar für heute Verhältnisse wunderbar konzise und poetisch zugleich – und das bei einem 50 Jahre alten Forschungsstand. Dick hat hier wunderbar hellsichtig analysiert und war deswegen in der Lage, eine überzeugende Welt zu skizzieren, die einem gelegentlich den Atem stocken lässt. Dies gelingt auch deshalb so gut, weil er Spiegelungen vornimmt, die seine Welt glaubhaft erscheinen lassen und dabei doch ausreichend exotisch bleiben: Wenn er zum Beispiel beschreibt, wie die Deutschen ihren Teil der USA mit massiven Finanzspritzen wieder aufbauen, um die Wirtschaft in ihrem eigenen Interesse wieder zum laufen zu bringen, so bringt die Nähe zum Marshallplan die nötige Bekanntheit des Vorganges; die Idee, das Rommel als Militärgouverneur diesen Vorgang von New York aus geleitet hat, verleiht ihm allerdings die nötige Exotik.

Und hier beginnt langsam der zweite Punkt, das literarisch famose Verwirrspiel, dass die Welt des Buches mit der Realität des Lesers verschränkt. Denn in dieser Welt existiert ein Buch, das eine alternative Welt beschreibt, in der die Alliierten den Krieg gewonnen haben, womit der Leser sich zum ersten Mal ertappt fühlt – und einer von Dicks Charakteren analysiert die „cheap tricks“ mit denen dieses Buch seine Spannung generiert, und der Leser fühlt sich zum zweiten Mal ertappt. Und ab da kann man nicht mehr anders, als ständig sowohl das Buch, als auch im direkten die eigene Realität zu analysieren. Wenn er beschreibt, wie die Briten nach dem Krieg für ihre Kriegsverbrechen zur Rechenschaft gezogen wurden und die absolute Überzeugung der Charaktere, dies sei zu Recht geschehen, greifbar wird, dann kann man nicht anders, als seine eigene politisch-historische Prägung zu hinterfragen. Was in anderen Büchern nur ein Setting, ein semioriginelles Worldbuilding ist, das ist bei „The Man in the High Castle“ ein Instrument, das im Gehirn des Lesers herumfuhrwerkt.

Aber das Buch ist, wie gesagt, auch völlig OHNE das Setting literarisch ein Genuss. Die Frage nach dem Sinn und Zweck der eigenen Existenz, der eigenen Handlungen, vor allem des eigenen Scheiterns und der eigenen Ohnmacht vor den höheren Gewalten – das wird von Dick so elegant, so schlank, so filigran durchexerziert, dass man nie wie so oft das Gefühl hat, hier eine vergleichende ethische Studie zu lesen, die bloß zufällig Romanform angenommen hat, sondern man ist wirklich jeweils in der Gedankenwelt und dem Wertesystem der Figuren gefangen.

Das Buch entlässt einen mit dem rasenden Wunsch, mehr von den Menschen und von der Welt zu erfahren. Gott sei Dank ist das nie geschehen. Das Buch besticht durch seine formvollendete Eleganz, keine Gramm Fett beschwert die Geschichte. Jedes Mehr hätte das Konstrukt vernichtet, und jede weitere Ausarbeitung hätte die Gefahr der Banalisierung beinhaltet – wenn man die ersten Kapitel der (glücklicherweise!!) verworfenen Fortsetzung liest, merkt man das sofort.

Klassiker werden oft nur gelesen, weil sie Klassiker sind. Danach nickt man anerkennend mit dem bildungsbürgerlichen Kopf und hat seine Pflicht getan.

Dicks High Castle ist anders. Dicks High Castle muss man lesen, weil es einem auch 50 Jahre später noch in den Hintern tritt.
Helfen Sie anderen Kunden bei der Suche nach den hilfreichsten Rezensionen 
War diese Rezension für Sie hilfreich? Ja Nein


3 von 3 Kunden fanden die folgende Rezension hilfreich
3.0 von 5 Sternen Visionäre Grundidee. Die Umsetzung jedoch, kann nicht überzeugen, 5. Juli 2012
Von 
callisto (Freiburg) - Alle meine Rezensionen ansehen
(TOP 500 REZENSENT)   
Was wäre, wenn Roosevelt 1933 nicht erschossen worden wäre? Hätte der Zweite Weltkrieg dann vor 1947 geendet und hätten vielleicht die Achsenmächte und nicht Deutschland und Japan den Krieg gewonnen und die Welt unter sich aufgeteilt? Diese Frage stellt sich der Autor Hawthorne Abendsen in seinem Roman 'The grasshopper lies heay', der in Festung Europa natürlich verboten ist, in den japanisch besetzten Gebieten und in der neutralen, kleinen, amerikanischen Pufferzone zwischen dem deutschen und japanischen Besatzungsgebiet jedoch ein Bestseller ist.

Großteils ist dieser Roman von Philipp K. Dick ein klassischer alternate history Roman, der natürlich das, besonders in den 1960er Jahren noch heiße Thema Nazideutschland behandelt. Dabei werden leider sämtliche damals herrschende Vorurteile und Klischees über Deutsche bedient: Zyniker, Perfektionisten, seelenlos, überheblich, blond...

"'['...] they're cynics with utter faith. It's a sort of brain defect, like a lobotomy'that maiming those German psychiatrists do as a poor substitute for psychotherapy.'"
"'They're all committing incest, [...']. That's why they, those elite SS fairies, have that angelic simper, that blond babylike innocence; they're saving themselves for Mama. Or for each other.'"
"'They identify with God's power and believe they are godlike. That is their basic madness. They are overcome by some archetype; their egos have expanded psychotically so that they cannot tell where they begin and the godhead leaves off. It is not hubris, not pride; it is inflation of the ego to its ultimate'confusion between him who worships and that which is worshiped.'"

Nebenbei scheint Philipp K. Dick auch ein Fan von James Joyce gewesen zu sein und versucht verzweifelt seinen Ulysses zu imitieren. Er beschreibt wenige Tage in dieser Welt aus verschiedenen Blickwinkeln an verschiedenen Orten. Ihre Handlungen beeinflussen einander, auch wenn sie sich nie begegnen. Die Handlungen sind dabei teilweise einfach nur trivial.
-Mr. Frink, Jude, geschieden, verliert seinen Job und macht mit einem ehemaligen Kollegen ein Schmuckatelier auf.
-Frinks Ex-Frau Juliana Frink, Judolehrerin in der Pufferzone, lernt einen attraktiven Italiener kennen und geht mit ihm auf Reisen
-Rudolf Wegener, deutscher Agent, nimmt Kontakt zur japanischen Seite auf.
-Robert Childan, 38 Jahre alt, Kunsthändler echter amerikanischer Vorkriegskunst, entdeckt in seinem Sortiment Fälschungen.
-Mr. Tagomi und seine Frau, Kunden von Robert Childan.

Dafür bedient sich der Autor umso mehr des inneren Monologs und schreibt zum Großteil auch den Text in dieser Sprunghaften, abgehackten Weise:
'"Only way is this, he decided. He felt grim, even desperate. Go to Ray Calvin. Confront him. Insist that he pursue matter back to source. Maybe he is innocent, too. Maybe not.'"
Die Protagonisten scheinen insgesamt alle eher gebrochen englisch zu sprechen.

Hinzu kommt, dass Philpp K. Dick immer wieder deutsche Sätze einstreut. Es war damals aber wohl unter der Würde des Autors, einen Muttersprachler die Grammatik und Rechtschreibung kontrollieren zu lassen. Die Deutschen Passagen sind fast alle auf die eine oder andere Art fehlerhaft, sei es grammatikalisch sinnentstellend (wie die Gute, statt das Gute), Formulierungen, die man so nie nutzen würde und Umlaute sind ohnehin eher Glückssache.

Warum nur, ist dieses Buch dann ein visionärer Klassiker der Science Fiction? Dafür gibt es eine einfache Erklärung: Die Grundidee dieses Romans: Das I Ging.
Es geht nicht nur um einen alternativen Geschichtsverlauf. Es geht darum, dass Philipp K. Dick in diese Roman das Prinzip, die Idee der Parallelwelten entwirft, lange bevor Quantenphysiker auf diese Idee kommen sollten und sie wissenschaftlich untermauern würden. Mittels des I Ging kann der Prophet vom Berg Hawthorne Abendsen Informationen aus diesem parallelen Universum herausfinden und sie als Roman veröffentlichen, diese Welt existiert irgendwo. Philipp K. Dick selber schrieb diesen Roman auch mit Hilfe des I Ging und lässt auch seine Protagonisten regelmäßig das Orakel befragen, Philipp K. Dick selbst ist also der Abendsen Hawthorne, unserer Welt.
Die Macher von Matrix setzten daher Philipp K. Dick mit der Figur ihres Orakels in der Matrix Trilogie ein Denkmal, denn auch dort vermittelt das Oracle zwischen den beiden Realitäten, der Welt da draußen und der Matrix.

So gesehen legt die Grundidee des Romans einen wichtigen Science Fiction Grundstein, entwirft eine visionäre Grundidee. Die Umsetzung jedoch kann nicht überzeugen.

Anmerkung zum Cover: Normalerweise finde ich es affig, wenn sich jemand über das Cover eines Buches auslässt. Hier muss ich aber darauf hinweisen, dass man das Buch auf keinen Fall auf Flugreisen lesen sollte. Das Hakenkreuz verstößt in Deutschland gegen das Gesetzt und einem Bekannten wurde daher bereits einmal ein amerikanischer Roman wegen des Titelbildes am Zoll konfisziert (Harris: Vatherland).
Helfen Sie anderen Kunden bei der Suche nach den hilfreichsten Rezensionen 
War diese Rezension für Sie hilfreich? Ja Nein


3 von 3 Kunden fanden die folgende Rezension hilfreich
5.0 von 5 Sternen Another Philip K. Dick Classic, 4. Mai 2011
Von 
Dr. Bojan Tunguz (Indiana, USA) - Alle meine Rezensionen ansehen
(REAL NAME)   
Philip K. Dick is a master of unconventional sci-fi and fantasy genre, and those qualities are clearly exhibited in this work. It is set in 1960s America in a world in which Germany and Japan have won the World War II. US and the rest of the world are divided between those two superpowers, and we follow lives of several ordinary Americans who try to adjust themselves to this reality. The characters in the novel are fully developed in a manner that we've come to expect from Dick's later novels. Their personal struggles are intertwined with the new geopolitical power plays. The title of the novel refers to the sobriquet for Hawthorne Abendsen, a fictional writer of the book "The Grasshopper Lies Heavy" which forms a story-within-a-story and a sort of MacGuffin for this novel. This fictional book will also be at the center of the denouement of this novel, and may provide the clue for what this novel was all about.

The Man in the High Castle is another brilliant and thought provoking novel. It is an engrossing and fun read as well, and a true classic of science fiction.
Helfen Sie anderen Kunden bei der Suche nach den hilfreichsten Rezensionen 
War diese Rezension für Sie hilfreich? Ja Nein


1 von 1 Kunden fanden die folgende Rezension hilfreich
5.0 von 5 Sternen Dick's Masterpiece, 15. Mai 2000
Rezension bezieht sich auf: The Man in the High Castle (Vintage) (Taschenbuch)
The Man in the High Castle is Dick's masterpiece. Along with VALIS and Do Androids Dream of Electric Sheep?, it completes the trilogy of the author's essential works. A must read for Dickheads or for anyone who considers himself a serious fan of science fiction. Dick was clearly influenced by two earlier works of alternative history, Sarban's The Sound of His Horn and C. M. Kornbluth's "Two Dooms". In turn, The Man in the High Castle has influenced any number of later works, not just Norman Spinrad's The Iron Dream and the novels of Harry Turtledove, but Ursula LeGuin's The Lathe of Heaven as well.
This is a very complex, suspenseful novel, consisting of four main plot lines and a host of characters whose lives sometimes interact. Don't expect any slam-bang pyrotechnic action here, despite the novel's provocative premise. It's more a slice of life tale, showing that even after a catastrophic defeat, life in America would go on. Dick is very good at detailing the nuances of life in Axis-ruled America. For example, at one point as an aside, it is pointed out that after the Nazi pograms, the only surviving prewar comedian is Bob Hope, and even he has to broadcast out of Canada. Also, an unintended irony for a novel written in 1962 is Dick's conjecture that if the United States had lost WWII, we would all be listening to Japanese audio equipment and driving German cars now. The author achieves the near impossible feat of actually being even-handed towards the Nazis without glamorizing them. He describes them at one point as Neanderthals in white lab coats, technological geniuses who have drained the Mediterranean and are conquering the Solar System, yet are morally bankrupt. Dick is much easier on the Japanese, depicting them not just as benign conquerors, but almost like a group of tourists, just off the latest JAL flight headed for the souvenir stand at Disneyland. Only in one brief instance when Juliana Frink reminiscences about conditions in San Francisco immediately after the occupation is their wartime rapacity even hinted at.
Several other reviewers here appear to be put off that the novel didn't live up to the action and dramatic tension hinted at in the synopsis above or the 1964 Popular Library cover with its map of the United States superimposed by Nazi and Imperial Japanese flags. When I first read it back in 1964 at age fourteen, I felt much the same way. On rereading it in 1988, however, I saw it for its true worth, an existential novel of the first order (ranking with the best of Camus or Sartre). It represents the fullest flowering of Dick's most consistent theme: What is reality? The provocative setting of an alternative universe where the Axis has won World War II and now occupies a defeated and humiliated America is merely a sensational back drop for Dick's real theme: how can we be sure of what is real? Thus the seemingly minor scene involving two Zippo lighters is actually the key to understanding the whole novel. One is merely a minor collectible, the other is priceless, Mr. Wyndam-Matson tells his mistress. What's the difference? The one was the actual lighter FDR was carrying when he was assassinated in 1934. But how does he know it is real? Well, he has a paper that certifies it is. But how does he know the paper is real? And so on. Likewise, the emphasis on the Japanese obsession with collecting authentic relics of America's prewar past is a symbolic of the authenticity which all the novel's characters are seeking in their own diverse ways. The anticlimactic and ambiguous ending also only serves to re-enforce what Dick was trying to say. In retrospect, he couldn't have ended it any other way. To neatly wrap things up would only subvert the novel's whole premise.
Helfen Sie anderen Kunden bei der Suche nach den hilfreichsten Rezensionen 
War diese Rezension für Sie hilfreich? Ja Nein


1 von 1 Kunden fanden die folgende Rezension hilfreich
5.0 von 5 Sternen Dick should be a Grand Master of SF, 3. Mai 2000
Von 
David N. Reiss (Haymarket, VA United States) - Alle meine Rezensionen ansehen
(REAL NAME)   
Rezension bezieht sich auf: The Man in the High Castle (Vintage) (Taschenbuch)
First off, I would just like to comment that I have never really liked the fact that SFWA requires that a writer be alive in order to be given the title "Grand Master". Philip K. Dick died in 1982, and was a realitivly young 54 at the time of his death. They almost didn't quiet make it in time to give the Grand Master award to Alfred Bester. They didn't make it in time for Dick, like Theodore Sturgeron, Henry Kuttner and John W. Campbell, as well as others. Phil Dick should be should be made a Grand Master of Science Fiction postumously. The Novels and Short Stories that Dick produced in his lifetime are some of the best SF ever written.
The Man in the High Castle is not your average SF novel. In some ways, it isn't an SF novel. It is set in an alternative history, which is about all that makes it SF except for the way it tells the story. If it was not written by "an SF author" it probably would not be considered SF by most people . But it is SF cause it deals with large ideas that most other literature wouldn't touch with a ten foot poll. Basically, it deals with a concept of what the future holds of humanity. The world it is set in is very alien to us. Nazi's -- pretty much nothing more than evil space aliens. Of course, evil space aliens that we are all too familure with. (Lets hope they remain nothing more than evil space aliens of literuture too. Once was one too many times for us as a species to play around with things like Nazism.)
In the end, the story line kind of just ends. It ends with a esoteric view on things in the book. A world where Nazi's and Japanese are competing in a Cold War that threats to flame into a hot war at any moment. Which all just acts as a backdrop... Ideas, the stuff of SF. Nazi's and Japanese Facists in control of the United States and most of the world... and it isn't even the point of it all. The novel is more about people trying to make their way in this world... and some how we might just make it through a lot of hash odds and make it all work out in the end.
The novel has a very cautious, but in the end, extreamly optimistic view of the human race and what the future holds for us. The novel, like our real lives, does not tell us what that future holds... just that if we play our cards right it can be a better place.
Philip K. Dick holds a unique vision of the world we live in. It might be bad, but even in the pits of hell a seed can take root that changes everything.
Helfen Sie anderen Kunden bei der Suche nach den hilfreichsten Rezensionen 
War diese Rezension für Sie hilfreich? Ja Nein


1 von 1 Kunden fanden die folgende Rezension hilfreich
4.0 von 5 Sternen Transcends its genre., 29. April 2000
Von 
Michael Bulger (Rochester, NY, USA) - Alle meine Rezensionen ansehen
(REAL NAME)   
Rezension bezieht sich auf: The Man in the High Castle (Vintage) (Taschenbuch)
Philip K. Dick, as some reading this might be aware, was a science fiction writer whose stories served (loosely) as the basis for the films "Blade Runner" and "Total Recall." His short fiction exemplifies the maxim that science fiction is a "literature of ideas." The "idea" behind "The Man in the High Castle" is that of the alternative history: the Axis powers actually prevailed in World War II, and modern-day America (meaning, in this case, the 1960's, when the book was first published) has been roughly split into two spheres of influence, German and Japanese.
How pleasantly surprising, then, to discover that this central "idea" is nothing more than a backdrop; that while plot and characters are certainly shaped by the imagined circumstances, the actual concern of the book is not the situation but the people within it. As a result, rather than reading as a description of an alternate reality, we are treated to a full experience of lives in a world that differs profoundly from our own. As a result, this novel is more than just science fiction. It succeeds in transcending the genre ghetto and meriting consideration among the best of modern writing.
Examples of how carefully, and how well, this book was thought out are too numerous to list, but one example: the titular "Man" is an American maverick writer of an alternative history in which America and its allies prevail in World War II. How simple, how convenient it would have been to have this alternative-history-within-an-alternative-history perfectly reflect our own reality. But it isn't so; the imagined history is completely different. Brilliantly conceived and executed, this is a truly rewarding book.
Helfen Sie anderen Kunden bei der Suche nach den hilfreichsten Rezensionen 
War diese Rezension für Sie hilfreich? Ja Nein


1 von 1 Kunden fanden die folgende Rezension hilfreich
5.0 von 5 Sternen A Work of Rare Brilliance, 27. November 1999
Rezension bezieht sich auf: The Man in the High Castle (Vintage) (Taschenbuch)
How does one even begin to describe this amazing book? As others have pointed out, there is little in the novel by way of plot or action, and I would also add that as a literary stylist P.K. Dick was no Marcel Proust. The ending of the book is deeply flawed, in my opinion, and gives one the impression that P.K. Dick simply ran out of steam and didn't quite know how to end the story.
...And yet...and yet..."The Man in the High Castle" remains a work of rare genius, despite all of the flaws within it. Very rarely does one came across a book so thought provoking, so moving, so well endowed with insight into the natures of men. P.K. Dick might as well have been writing a critique of the America or the Soviet Union of his own day, for all the insight he brought to bear in this alternative history.
Dick's description of life as a citizen of an occupied country rings with an accuracy that is usually possible only for one who has experienced the humiliation of subjection oneself. Robert Childan might as well have been an African-American or an Indian living under the Raj, and his feelings towards himself and his masters would have been little different. If the America of the present day or the India of the British colonial era hardly seem the moral equivalent of what life might have been like under the Japanese, it is only because those whose tales are told are the conquerors', not because of any moral superiority inherent in Anglo-Saxon life.
Dick's gives an indication of how many Japanese of the WWII generation must feel about the United States' post-war occupation and its eternally self-serving justifications of its own actions. If the Co-Prosperity Sphere was a sham, what are we to make of America's occupation of the Phillipines after that country's war of independence from Spain? How to reconcile America's support for the French colonial presence in Vietnam in the 1950s and 1960s with its avowed mission to halt Japanese colonial expansion in the late 1930s? What can explain away American support for Jonas Savimbi, Mobutu Sese Seko, Fidel Marcos and countless other unsavory, thieving butchers the world over? Could it be - Heaven forbid! - that for all the brutality of the Japanese' campaigns in East Asia, we have been every bit as immoral as they were? "The Man in the High Castle" dares to say "Perhaps so," and it is for this heretical notion that it deserves a 5-star rating and more.
Helfen Sie anderen Kunden bei der Suche nach den hilfreichsten Rezensionen 
War diese Rezension für Sie hilfreich? Ja Nein


1 von 1 Kunden fanden die folgende Rezension hilfreich
2.0 von 5 Sternen I don't get it., 21. Oktober 1999
Rezension bezieht sich auf: The Man in the High Castle (Vintage) (Taschenbuch)
I agree with many of the other reviewers that the set up of the book is nice. Japan occupies the Western USA while Germany occupies the East, and seemingly has some not-well-defined power over the West as well (e.g. Jews found living in the West are arrested and transported to German territory). White Americans are bitter and/or try to get along with their conquerers the best they can. Black Americans are re-enslaved (but that takes up maybe 0.1% of the book).
The characters are interesting as well. So is the existence in this alternate universe of a book of alternate history, in which the Allies win the war. Also interesting is when Fuehrer Bormann dies and the world anxiously awaits who will succeed him: Goebbels or Heynrich?
Unfortunately, Dick takes this great set up and blows it badly. The characters spend tremendous amounts of time doing I Ching and explaining the nonsensical results which, like all fortune telling, can mean anything anybody wants it to mean. The book is bogged down in New Age, fake Eastern mysticism. Well, I guess for all I know it is authentic Eastern mysticism, but it does nothing for my Western mind. And really, the great set up seems only designed to let Dick give us pointless Chinese poetry and superstition. I guess this was ground-breaking stuff back in 1962, but is boring today. Might I suggest Xenocide by Orson Scott Card as an example of Chinese mysticism with a point.
I might have given the book three stars but for the silly non-ending. The ending is as inscruable as all the deep and meaningless poetry that fills the book. The ending is perhaps supposed to be a Zen koan. Blech.
If you want to read "groundbreaking," somewhat science fictionish, alternate historyish stuff from the same time period that holds up well today, I suggest Cat's Cradle by Kurt Vonnegut. That book also contains nonsensical mysticism and poetry, but the difference is that in Cat's Cradle, the mysticism is fake and everyone knows it and no one takes it seriously.
Helfen Sie anderen Kunden bei der Suche nach den hilfreichsten Rezensionen 
War diese Rezension für Sie hilfreich? Ja Nein


1 von 1 Kunden fanden die folgende Rezension hilfreich
5.0 von 5 Sternen A Warning From Alternative History, 25. Januar 2000
Rezension bezieht sich auf: The Man in the High Castle (Vintage) (Taschenbuch)
It is easy to see why so many readers have a probelem with the ending of this book. I, too, found it rather unsatisfactory. The dillema with conceiving such a story is that there perhaps can be no satisfactory end. The meagre handful of frightened and unorganised disenters left under German and Japanese co-rule could not plausibly have risen up and struck back. So the ending we are ofered is somewhat ambiguous. It reflects the hopes of the individuals under oppression. Individual psychosis. Unfortunately, and darkly, the note is not bright. The sinistry of the preceeding events, the situation that continues to escalate beyond the final page, clouds any hope for change. However, the striking inversion of one of history's most pivotal periods offers much to contemplate, and the display of the characters' unspoken racism is so subtle, it would seem, to themselves, but to us the readers... so tragic. In this, there is little hope. A great rot is infecting the human race in this world. There is surely the question: what of the evil in world war do we inherit in our world. But Dick convinces us that the way things could have turned out would have been infinitely worse. I have not come across anything quite like this before, and it has fuelled my urge to read more of Dick's work. The Man In The High Castle also works as companion to Radio Free Albemuth, in that a similar scenario occurs. (Don't expect much of a soul-satisfying ending in that one either).
Helfen Sie anderen Kunden bei der Suche nach den hilfreichsten Rezensionen 
War diese Rezension für Sie hilfreich? Ja Nein


‹ Zurück | 1 27 | Weiter ›
Hilfreichste Bewertungen zuerst | Neueste Bewertungen zuerst

Dieses Produkt

The Man in the High Castle (Vintage)
The Man in the High Castle (Vintage) von Philip K. Dick (Taschenbuch - 30. Juni 1992)
Gebraucht & neu ab: EUR 6,63
Auf meinen Wunschzettel Zahlungsmöglichkeiten ansehen
Nur in den Rezensionen zu diesem Produkt suchen