Hilfreichste kritische Rezenzion
0 von 1 Kunden fanden die folgende Rezension hilfreich.
Superior Episode, Inferior Novel
am 20. Oktober 1999
Normally, I Give all Star Trek books an open mind but this novel wasnt very good, Dont get me wrong, I normally like Diane Carey's books, But She needs to research more on the show, Especially the Crew Positions and stop adding un-seen scenes, unless they were from a script, say if I was someone that hasn't seen the episode, and read the book first, then watch the Episode, You'd be expecting to see more scenes than you should, and if you posted that on a newsgroup or in a chat room, and after you were told, You'd either feel like an idoit or the other people may call you an idiot, But The reason I Gave this 2 Stars is, 5 for the episode, and subtract 3 from the novel.