Kunden diskutieren > englische bücher Diskussionsforum

Was Sherlock Holmes asexual?


Sortieren: Ältester zuerst | Neuester zuerst
1-6 von 6 Diskussionsbeiträgen
Ersteintrag: 19.01.2013 21:43:18 GMT+01:00
Zuletzt vom Autor geändert am 19.01.2013 21:44:34 GMT+01:00
While doing background research for my Victorian crime novels, I came across several articles discussing Sherlock Holmes potentially being asexual. As per definition, an asexual is a person who does not experience sexual attraction.
Today I had a long discussion with David Jay, founder of the Asexuality Network (www.asexuality.org) on asexuality, Sherlock Holmes and his relationship with Watson, his view of Victorian women, as well as the great difference in perception of sexuality between the Victorian era and today. To say that my horizon got broadened, would be an understatement.
But I would like to know what avid readers and Sherlock Holmes fans think about that.
Could Sherlock Holmes be described as asexual or not?

The Devil's Grin (Kronberg Crimes)

Veröffentlicht am 20.01.2013 17:49:30 GMT+01:00
Librarian meint:
I think not.
In my opinion his appreciation of women is concentrated on the intellectual level. The only women he could speak of in an admiring manner was Irene Adler, and that was a woman with huge intellect, almost or even totally on par with his own. He probably just could not fall in love with a woman who was not in his own league, intellectually. As Sherlock Holmes was supposed to be of genius intellect, that would make it probably very few eligibly women, and he probably just did not meet the right one, nor was he inclined to devote too much time searching, when solving crimes was so satisfying to him.

Veröffentlicht am 24.01.2013 13:31:52 GMT+01:00
[Die meisten Kunden meinen, dass dieser Beitrag nicht zur Diskussion gehört. Beitrag dennoch anzeigen. Alle nicht nützlichen Einträge anzeigen.]

Veröffentlicht am 30.01.2013 12:54:25 GMT+01:00
Dev meint:
Canon: Yes.

Fan interpretations: everything goes.

Veröffentlicht am 30.01.2013 17:08:20 GMT+01:00
Zuletzt vom Autor geändert am 31.01.2013 18:44:12 GMT+01:00
Gerd Dürner meint:
Have been asking myself the same question just recently.
Fact is that Watson tells us that Holmes was never romantically interested in a woman, with the possible exception of Irene Adler.

I think it's fair to conclude from that, that Holmes was aromantic, but if he was asexual too is hard to say, just because Watson never mentions any romantic urges (read: sexual) doesn't mean they may not have been had in some way or other.

Veröffentlicht am 31.01.2013 12:17:04 GMT+01:00
'I, of course, have never loved' - it's a mild misquote from Holmes - and a lie. Watson falls in love with - and later marries Mary Morstan, who we meet in The Sign of Four - despite Watson thinking himself inadequate (old and a retired army doctor on half pay). The point is this - at the time of writing there were a lot of people that chose to live alone - and no one cared. Holmes has the perfect batchelor life - he lives in central London, knows everybody, works for himself - and, given his love of narcotics - is blessed to have a doctor as his best mate.
‹ Zurück 1 Weiter ›
[Kommentar hinzufügen]
Schreiben Sie einen Beitrag zu dieser Diskussion
Verwenden Sie zum Einfügen eines Produktlinks dieses Format: [[ASIN:ASIN Produkt-Name]] (Was ist das?)
Eingabe des Log-ins
 


Kürzliche Einträge in englische bücher Diskussionsforum (571 Diskussionen)

 

Zur Diskussion

Teilnehmer:  6
Beiträge insgesamt:  6
Erster Beitrag:  19.01.2013
Jüngster Beitrag:  31.01.2013

Neu! Bei neuen Einträgen eine E-Mail erhalten.
Von 1 Kunden verfolgt

Kundendiskussionen durchsuchen