Collins and Ogilvie-Herald present a very plausible investigation into, not only the real story of the discovery of Tutankhamun's tomb, but also the significance of his 'lost' papyri. The level of research, detail and presentation is quite impressive and this alone makes the book worth reading, whether or not you agree with their conclusions.
With regard to Mr. Crowe's review:
There is nothing in the text of this book that supports such rubbish as the "Holocaust denial movement". He seems to have picked one bad apple off the tree and made a meal of it, perhaps in support of his own agenda, fixation and witch hunt.
As for Mr. Cerny's review, I doubt he even read the work in its entirety.
There is nothing in the book about a clerk overhearing anything. The person that recorded Carter's story was his North American lecture agent, Lee Keedick, President of the Keedick Lecture Bureau, who was never in Egypt. It is doubtful that Cerny even bothered to read the work in its entirety before submitting his review.