I was very excited to get this book - unedxpectedly as I did. I had asked a question in a fly shop and the owner showed this book to me, I bought it, then read it cover to cover. As a fly-fisherman from upstate NY, this book solved many of my curiosities about fishing in PA. I now feel I know where I want to go, and why I want to go to these certain streams.
What I think Meck did well is the following. He knows where he's going - he's been to these rivers. His personal experiences, along with describing local fly fishermen from many of the streams, lent a degree of authenticity to his reviews. I think he was pretty honest about some streams that are not as good now as others, or maybe as good now as they were themselves in the past. He does a great job I felt with describing the temperature situations and how they vary not only from stream to stream but within a stream as well. He also does a nice job reminding us how to be good conservationists as we fish, and what our role can be if we were to live in the area - with helping out the local agencies that are trying to support and protect these streams.
What he is really good at - but which I could do less with - is the hatch information. I understand how some people really want that info, but I found it very redundant, telling how they each have essentially many of the same hatches - during most of the same weeks - over and over and over. He does a very thorough job with this, he's very good at it, just as a reader, it was more than I personally wanted.
What I would have liked to see more of - and this is just me - is more of the recommendations for inns, diners, etc. I guess that comes from an out of stater - that would be for someone else to write about I guess. Also, I found some issues with the maps. If you have a section on a certain steam, they should be on the map. Sometimes they weren't. I'm sure I saw a few errors as well on some points.
Overall, i enjoyed the book a lot. It gave me a very good background to fly fishing PA. I now feel confident that I will purchase a PA fishing license and head to PA to leave some of my money in it's economy.