This book was scheduled as one of my SF book club's discussion books. I wasn't completely enthused about it since I had read Weber's Honor Harrington series (which I enjoyed immensely!) and felt sure that it would be a knock-off. Boy was I wrong!
This book has fine characterization, interesting plotlines, and a universe that kept me turning the pages all night.
While I couldn't stop at this first book (Starpilot's Grave and By Honor Betray'd are books 2+3), this book could be read as a stand-alone for those who aren't prepared to dive into a multi-book series.
As mentioned in several of the other reviews, this book is reminiscent of the Star Wars universe with some science fiction elements and a bit of the supernatural.
What appealed most, however, was that the authors built a sense of history into their universe so that there is a feeling that the crises recounted here are the result of real historical events. In addition, the reader does not have an omniscient view of the action, because many of the characters do not have a complete understanding. This made the plot more realistic.
This is definitely a book to put on the "re-read" shelf.