This book was, at least in my opinion, the most frustrating that there was. As for as the plot goes, the book rocked. Yes true, it should have been longer, ALL the Jedi apprentice books should be, but this is not my point. First, it seems that the character of Obi-wan is being made inferior. I understand that being so young, inexperienced, and just starting his journey to become a Jedi, leaves him slightly incompetent, but in this book especially, it seems that everyone has managed to progress, or are naturally superior to him. And I am not referring to the actual statement (when he himself fears that everyone's progressing, and him standing till) or constant criticism he was getting from the council and mistreatment (like when Mace compliments Bant and scolds him. That I applaud the author on her uncanny ability to reflect adult behavior...a certain subliminal persecution from adults to children who've made then cross). It is already frustrating to read about Anakin's greatness, and how Obi-wan lacked in such superiority as to reach to Anakin's level, but it's hard to believe that one of the greatest Jedi that ever lived seems more like a "mook", and void of all talent. Would it be so hard to bless our hero with an outstanding ability at SOMETHING?...After all, Anakin reflected other talents without the experienced of force, and he was wasn't much younger than Obi-wan was...it's just hard to believe that Obi-wan is good for NOTHING, and lacks any talent- force oriented ones or not. Bant too seems to lend to this. I support the idea of female characters in the "Star Wars" universe, but it seemed that she was the source of all brilliant ideas and good ideology...like all the female characters that appeared in this series, she seems "perfect" (also see Tahl). Funny how the more realistic "scarred" characters are all male, and this "streak of realism" in character is restricted only to our Obi-wan, and immoral characters. While I understand that the author wanted to show us a certain transformation in character, and understanding on Obi-wan's behalf (that he made a mistake by leaving the order), I would have preferred that he reflected some sort of self-insite on the situation...not run to the all knowing Bant for answers. Asides form this, the book's plot kept me on the edge of my seat (even thought it was pretty obvious who the culprits were) and I would recommend it to all who read that series so far, and who enjoy Qui-gon-Obi-wan stories.