Detailed and disturbing in its portrait of a demented, racist killer, 'The Butcher's Theatre' delivers plausible and - three cheers - genuinely interesting characters in an unusually exotic location.
This is the first of Kellerman's novels I have read, and must confess that it was the setting that initially attracted me. Those who love Israel and Jerusalem can revel in a tale that deals with murder and sexual depravity in a society where bloody family quarrels and the horror of political terrorism are the norms. They can also rejoice, as I did, in descriptions of the city that do justice to its beauty.
The tension generated by ignorance and decades of habitual racial intolerance fades as the very different detectives in Sharavi's team learn to resolve their differences and work together to catch a psychopath.
As well as the analysis of the serial killer which I suppose, given his psychologist background, is to be expected of Kellerman, he deserves credit for credible insights into the lives of his detectives outside the case. From Sharavi's experiences in the '67 war to Schmeltzer's bitterness over the deaths of his wife and son, finally to North Tel-Aviv rich-kid Cohen and the concept of protekzia; we are presented with characters to think about.
In fact, one of my few gripes about a more or less flawless read was the absence of the Chinaman or Schmeltzer in the closing pages. What happened to the latter's burgeoning relationship with Eva, hmm?
In conclusion, I had no reservations about the book's ending; I thought it was intriguing, well executed (no pun intended) , not to mention suitably gruesome. The ambiguity surrounding the future of Avi Cohen frustrated me deeply - but only because I was so desperate to tie up all those pesky loose ends! Congratulations to Jonathan Kellerman! I should add that finding out that Pakad Dani Sharavi is due to feature in another novel absolutely made my day. I look forward to renewing our acquaintance. I've not been so impressed with a novel since reading King and Straub's The Talisman, and Pat Barker's Regeneration trilogy. Both radically different sure, but masterpieces nontheless. 'The Butcher's Theatre' is up there with them. Truly a triumph.