Six Spices is a fine introduction to making tasty and healthful food in the aromatic style of India. You will have no problem finding any of the six spices: coriander, cumin, chile (dried and fresh), ginger, mustard seed and tumeric (fresh or powdered).
It looks a trifle suspicious when a successful book, to wit, "5 Spices 50 Dishes" is getting a perfect score here on Amazon, that another one rolls by, smelling quite close. Do we need this book?
To be sure, Kahate has a nice book in "5 & 50". It has good purpose and scope, namely to introduce the fundamentals of Indian cuisine. Indian food is the most complex in its preparation and execution that I have ever encountered, on average. It is not the most difficult in technique, but there are, again on average, more steps than any other cuisine I know. "5 Spices..." solves this barrier by introducing a simple approach to fundamentals.
So why Six? Maybe not if you already have 5. But here are my reasons to choose this one:
- Chilies are the sixth spice. Saluja includes just enough for those of us that love Indian hot
- Hardbound for close to the same price. This book is well made for decades of use. It lays flat on your
counter!
- Better organized. I like a section to tell me how to make food by seasoning in hot oil, and then the next
for clarified butter, a.k.a. ghee. Then powdered spice, then curry paste. Finally, a chapter looking to
more complete meals.
- More than "50" recipes, but thoughtfully so.
I have some minor aesthetic reasons as well. I like their publisher, Jones Books, in Madison, WI. I like not needing a named food photographer. I like the use of "Six" rather than "5 and 50" because numbers suggest or suppose other purposes, such as serial numbers and the like. All this is my small beer.
Buy both if you can. But get cooking with them.