I read a lot of very negative reviews about this book but decided to pick it up anyway. That'll teach me! I have certainly read worse books than "Starcrossed" (*cough* Breaking Dawn *cough* ) but this one still does rank pretty high on my "Wish I hadn't wasted time on this" list.
And, you know, the thing is that the basic idea of the story had potential. I could totally see this becoming an interesting story. Unfortunately, a good idea does not necessarily make a good book. It always depends on what the writer makes of the idea, and while I applaud Ms. Angelini for picking something other than vampires, angels or werewolves for her story, it has to be said that she isn't a great writer (yet).
The first roughly 100 or so pages of "Starcrossed" were bad. Ridiculously, cringeworthy, eyeroll-inducingly bad. Nothing in those pages made sense, the characters were completely flat and all behaved very immature, and I did at some point wonder whether this book was written by a 12-year-old. And yet I kept reading because it was so bad it was actually entertaining. It was like driving by an accident --- you know you don't want to see it, but you can't stop yourself from looking, either.
Anyway, it got better after that. Marginally. See, it seems that after those 100 or so pages Ms. Angelini finally remembered that characterization should actually be part of a book. Any book. So she tried to give her characters more depth --- which worked to a degree. I was able to relate to the characters a little more but they still did remain pretty one-dimensional throughout the entire book.
The main protagonist in "Starcrossed" is a teenage girl named Helen Hamilton who lives with her father on the beautiful island of Nantucket. She's tall, blonde, and very beautiful. Over the course of the beginning of the book we find out that Helen has quite a few abilities --- she's super strong and super fast, she has incredible hearing, she can fly, she can generate lightning ... oh, and did I mention that she can't be hurt by *any* weapon??? Really, it was just a *little* too much for my taste.
Now with all those abilities you'd think Helen would be one tough, confident, kick-ass girl, but no --- she's actually weak and childish and full of insecurities.I didn't dislike her exactly, but I didn't really like her, either. In fact, half the time I just found her really annoying. She is also very accepting of anything and everything. Whether it's the fact that she is stronger and faster than everybody she knows, or that she can fly, or that she is one of the Scions --- descendants of the mythological Greek gods --- she always simply accepts everything as reality without so much as the bat of an eyelash. There is barely a moment of disbelief or anything. Unfortunately it's like that for the entire book --- she almost never questions anything that she is told or that happens to her!
Helen is also a very passive character. For example, when Cassandra tries to kill her because that's what she saw herself doing in one of her visions, all Helen thinks is that if Cassandra foresaw her death then there would be no point in fighting back or resisting anyway. So she does nothing. Really? Seriously? She just sits there while she waits for Cassandra to behead her with a sword? Any normal person would have panicked and run away or fought back ... or at least thought about running or fighting back. But Helen goes for "sacrificial lamb" instead.
Then there's the male lead character --- Lucas Delos, a gorgeous boy who has just moved to the island with his family. The first time Helen sees Lucas she starts feeling uncontrollable hate, runs towards him and tries to throttle him or something like that. When she meets him again for the next time near his family's home she barrels right into him as soon as she sees him and they start fighting. Again, she never questions the instant hate she feels toward Lucas and the other members of the Delos family, or the "Why" behind the fact that she wants to kill him. Somewhere around page 100 or so they suddenly stop hating each other --- no real explanation for this is given by the author. I guess she expects her readers to be like Helen and just --- can you guess? --- accept it ...!
Lucas and Helen are supposed to be these tragic starcrossed lovers, but really ... there was nothing in the book that made me think "Oh yeah, those two are meant to be together ...". They go from instant hate (at the beginning of the book) to instant attraction (a little later). There is no base or reason for their love, though. You know how some books have really beautiful love stories that make you smile and sigh and basically make your toes curl? This isn't one of them.
And, you know, talk about sending mixed signals! After they get over their initial hatred for each other Lucas constantly holds Helen's hand or hugs her, he gives her smoldering glances ... there is one occasion where he lies with her IN HER BED (her under the covers, him on top ... sound familiar?), and he's holding her and kissing her neck ... but basically the moment she tries to touch him he says "We can't" ... while still nuzzling her neck, of course. In another situations she tells him that she's mad at him for leading him on (which he did) and then he gets mad at her for saying that ... Hello?
Let's move on to Helen's best friend Claire --- her reaction when Helen tells her that she can fly (and do other stuff) is absolutely ridiculous! So we're supposed to believe that Claire has know about all of this for a good 10 years and never mentioned it to anyone -- even Helen herself? That a 7-year-old girl would push her best friend of a roof and try to cut her with a knife simply to prove her theories?
The Delos family itself had a few mildly interesting characters but they did remind me a little too much of the Cullen family in "Twilight". Halfway through the book I realized that the character I liked best of everyone in this story was actually Lucas' psychotic cousin Hector. Well, he was really only psychotic in the beginning. But really, after a while I noticed that he was really the only one with a good head on his shoulders, the only one whose thoughts went in a reasonable direction.
I hate it when YA paranormal romance books automatically get compared to "Twilight" but in this case there is really no avoiding it. Did Ms. Angelini get inspired (read: steal) from the "Twilight" series? You bet she did. There are too many parallels for it to be otherwise. She merely exchanged vampires and werewolves for Greek mythology and the descendants of Greek Gods.
________________________________________________________________________
Here are some examples of the writing and my thoughts while I was reading the book:
"One of the terrible side effects of feeling as if she somehow already knew Lucas was that she was starting to idealize him, making him more perfect than was humanly possible." ... followed by ... "Which was uncomfortable because she also still wanted to kill him."
--- Why does she feel like she already knows him? And why does she want to kill him? She has only seem him twice and hasn't even talked to him yet!
"You just helped me, and I'm grateful. But I still really, really want to kill you." ... and then he says "This is hard for me, too, you know"
--- No, why should she know? They don't know each other at all, after all ...!
"Lucas was like her. The thought made her stomach heave. How could she be anything like someone she hated so desperately?"
--- Ah, right. And how does she know she's like him again? For that matter, how does she know what he's like anyway?
Imagine Lucas saying this *right* after he and Helen had been fighting to the death: "Damn it. They can't find you here or you're dead. Go!"
--- Wait, a moment ago he wanted to kill her, and now he wants her to run away so she *doesn't* get killed? Make up your mind, already ...
"The furies wanted her to kill Lucas, that was clear ..."
--- Really? Why is that clear? And why isn't she the least bit bothered by the thought of killing someone she doesn't even know?
"Helen had no doubt he (Lucas) wanted to kill her ..." and a little later "An ancient, supernatural force ewas compelling her to kill Lucas."
--- And yet she never even asks herself why ... personally, I would have demanded quite a few answers from someone at some point ...
"If paper could cut her but a spear couldn't, could you make a spear out of paper and kill her?"
--- Need I comment this one? A spear made out of paper ... right ...
This coming from Helen after hovering in front of her best friend's bedroom window and thus "coming out" to her with her new ability: "I just flew in your window. Why aren't you more surprised?" ... followed by Claire saying "I've known you could fly since we were kids. I even pushed you off your roof once to make sure."
--- Really? I don't even know what to say to that one ...
__________________________________________________________________________
Basically, I quickly lost track of how often I raised my eyebrows and asked myself "But WHY???" --- it happened a few times on every page! Anyway, like I said, it wasn't the worst book ever, but it wasn't good, either.