In his introduction to the Biographical Dictionary of Cinema, the (Cliche!) greatest book ever written on the cinema (because it values humanism and impressionism over sterile science and yet still produces comparable insights. Compare his entry on Sirk and all those deadly 70s Screen articles on the melodrama), David Thomson hoped that readers would wrestle with the book, and make their own impressions sharper. This is certainly the case with his (cliche!) astonishing, yet maddening Orson Welles biography, Rosebud. The book is astonishing in its insight, human sympathy, narration; in it's commingling of hoary legend and hard-won facts to create a vivid, yet satisfyingly elusive portrait of America's greatest (along with Hawks!) filmmaker. THe device of the dialogue with the imaginary publisher is wonderfully unstuffy, and helps qualify some of the sternness in the 'main' sections. It's formal mirroring of and continual alluding to Citizen Kane cements the power of his biographical interpretation of that masterpiece. Having read the book, it is evident why Kane is the greatest, why it's such a rich and everlasting work. His analysis of the opening scenes are the best ever written, and almost make you long for a complete study. Most astonishing however, no less so for being predictable, is the Thomson style, the complete opposite of the Welles' aesthetic, graceful, playful, Nabakovian, allusive, yet similarly moving and melancholic. What irritates about the book is the tendency to moralise and judge Welles, as if we were all perfect. It's one thing to criticise the work (and although some of his verdicts seem capricious, it's refreshing to see Macbeth, THe Trial adn F For Fake get their due), the repeated harping on Welles' failure as a human being grate (although I may be too adoring of the monster for my own good). This callousness softens towards the end, and when THomson confesses that his own personality is too close to Welles, and that he has been a shaping influence on his life, all becomes clear and (a la Thomson!) forgiveable.