I loved reading about the origins, form and analysis of the songs as i listened to them, particularly. The paragraphs that describe each song are a strange mixture of contextual knowledge, musical analysis, and historical background all of which are enjoyable to read about - but in some places Macdonald is *too* quick to dismiss songs, at least in my opinion. It is good that the accounts are more objective than many accounts obviously created by fanatics, but I can find something good in every beatles song I hear, *every* one, and the author is a little quick to call certain tracks 'throwaways'et cetera. Fortunately this doesnt retract from a very good read, and can act as a good reference book for years to come.