Produktinformation
|
Vorgeschlagene Tags zu ähnlichen Produkten(Was ist das?)Setzen Sie den ersten relevanten Tag hinzu (ein Schlüsselwort, das mit diesem Produkt in engem Zusammenhang steht).
|
Die Form (old frame Chen, erste Form. 75 Bewegungen) ist sehr gut erklärt und mit Bilder detailiert. Natürlich ist es völlig unmöglich, die Form nur vom Buch zu lernen - ohne Lehrer kann man Tai Chi nicht lernen - aber die Bewegungen werden sehr gut beschrieben und sind nicht schwer nachzumachen.
Der Autor schreibt zu Beginn des Buches "This is the book that I wished I had when I started Taijiquan", also "das ist das Buch dass ich, als ich anfing, Tai Chi zu lernen, gern gehabt hätte" - und genau dafür ist das Buch auch gut.
Ich kann es für die Leute, die sich für den alten Chen Stil interessieren, wärmstens empfehlen. Das Buch ersetzt keineswegs einen Lehrer, aber es ist als Lektüre zusätzlich zum Tai Chi-Training perfekt geeignet. Ich gebe dem Buch fünf Sterne, alle ehrlich verdient. Viel Spaß damit.
I am not a Tai Chi expert so cannot comment on the technical merits of the book. Being a non-authority, however, did not prevent me from having many "ah hah!" moments whilst reading the text. After many years of practice, under more than a few teachers and styles, Mark Chen answered questions which had plagued me --- and left unaswered until now --- throughout my martial arts lifetime. A single insight would have justified the cost of the book, and there have been many (for myself).
This book is certain to irritate some readers because Mark Chen attacks some "sacred cows". For example, any mention of Bruce Lee and Jeet Kune Do will inevitably invite criticism from Bruce's many supporters. Mark's definitions of martial art vs sport will aggravate an even larger audience.
If I could offer any criticism it would be a desire to have more detail in some of the sections. But, I suspect that may have defeated the intent of the author. In any case, the book is a classic as it is.
To compare Mark Chen's writing to another author might be instructive. Although I have the greatest respect for author Yang Jwing-Ming, I find his books a perplexing admixture of esoteric, technical and spiritual themes. The material is present but much harder (for me), than Mark Chen, to get to and assimilate the material.
In summary, in my opinion, a valuable contribution to the martial arts literature for all practitioners.
Mark Chen's strikingly comprehensive Chen Taiji manual offers quality photos with direction arrows, a nice breakdown of push hands training, solid attempts at explaining the basics - including 'Fajing' and "Issuing", very interesting commentary on weapons training, and offers a very nice sample of applications that manage to capture the unique neutralization and joint locking skills of which Chen Taiji is famed.
And as a long-time practitoner and researcher on Chen Taiji, I really appreciated his sourcing, excellent endnotes, and beautifully distilled statements that really capture what Chen Taiji is about. He accomplishes this in a way that is both 'traditional' in tone, yet highly practical in explanation.
He makes interesting assertions, most of which I agree with, a few I don't. But the overall statement he makes throughout the book will be quite revealing for those new to Chen Taiji and for adherents of any Taijiquan style looking to deepen their appreciation and understanding of this martial art. This work is a quality contribution to Chen Taiji literature in English.
|
Das Forum zu diesem Produkt
Fragen stellen, Meinungen austauschen, Einblicke gewinnen Aktive Diskussionen in ähnlichen Foren
Kundendiskussionen durchsuchen
|
Ähnliche Foren
|
||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
|
|
|