I am not alone in praising Mightier than the Sword: Uncle Tom's Cabin and the Battle for America, by American Studies scholar David Reynolds. The New York Times published an extended review about the book's significance--and particularly underscored the fresh challenges of returning this best-selling melodrama with all its problematic content to American classrooms. Reappraising Harriet Beecher Stowe's accomplishment makes for quite an educational challenge.
Nevertheless, as the Times pointed out: "If ever there was a publishing event to prove the principle that timing is everything, Uncle Tom's Cabin was it. On both sides of the sectional divide the timber was dry--and Stowe struck the igniting spark. In the North, Frederick Douglass rejoiced that she had `baptized with holy fire myriads who before cared nothing for the bleeding slave.'"
That's why I'm giving American Studies scholar David S. Reynolds' new book 5 stars. This is more than an individual book of history. It's part of the dramatic rewriting of what Americans thought we knew about the Civil War era and its long legacy. There are countless examples involving all aspects of that turbulent era--but, simply within the realm of racial politics, a great deal is changing in our assumptions about the Civil War's legacy. One example is the work of historian David Blight in a book like Race and Reunion: The Civil War in American Memory, where he completely overturns our previous nostalgic memories of Memorial Day. A second example, further along in that legacy, is Daniel L. Buttry's new book Blessed Are The Peacemakers, which includes a series of fresh profiles of Freedom Riders that helps to rewrite our assumptions about their origins and training as nonviolent activists in the South. This vital area of American history and culture is starting to look quite different in today's college classrooms.
In his new book, Reynolds invites readers to turn their assumptions on end about Uncle Tom's Cabin and Stowe's influence on our history. I've been a journalist covering issues of culture and diversity for more than 30 years--but as a Baby Boomer who majored in literature and writing in the early 1970s, no professor even suggested we should read Uncle Tom's Cabin. Now, we recognize that this best-selling 19th-century melodrama ranks with Dickens and even surpasses Dickens' ability to spark real change in the world.
You'll enjoy this book, including its sprinkling of illustrations. It's great for group discussion, and at only 273 pages in the main text, you'll find that even the slower readers in your group will finish this book quickly. They'll come to your discussion circle with lots to talk about!