I'm sorry if this is long... but believe me, keeping it this small was incredibly difficult. please read on, I have tried to make this as complete and informative as possible.
Circle of Blood should be hailed as one of the great achievements of modern literature. It is certainly the best ever within the comic medium. I have not read David Mack's run on Daredevil, nor do I care to. I have, however, read every volume of Kabuki, and they blow me away. Circle of Blood is a story so amazing I can't believe a person wrote it. I once told David Mack that he is like a God to me. I could only explain why to someone who has already read Circle of Blood. I'll try to stick to things that are relevant to those of you who haven't.
David Mack's artwork is amazing. It is the most creative I have ever looked at. He tells the story as much with the pictures as with the text... its hard to explain, but once again I have to say you will only truly understand if you read it yourself. I'm sure some people might not like the artwork in Circle of Blood as much as the beautifully painted pages of Dreams, Skin Deep, or Metamorphosis (Kabuki volumes 2, 4, 5) because it is in strict black and white. not even shades of grey, just black and white. This is intentional and deliberate. It's not for budget or time constraints, its done for a very specific reason, and those who have read all the different Kabuki books know that Mack uses different mediums for different moods and different types of stories. Kabuki books are best read with close attention to detail... you get the most out of it if you take in the art slowly and attentively and look at everything on the page.
In response to another reviewer who found Mack's portrayal of Japanese culture offensive and ignorant, I have only to say that I understand why that reviewer had the opinion he or she did, if he or she thought that was David Mack's perception of what Japan actually is. However, this story is fictional, and set in a future timeframe that is not meant to reflect modern OR traditional Japanese culture, but rather a mixture of both, twisted and perverted into something new, dark, even evil.
To those of you with short attention spans, you'll probably find this book boring. But it is far from it. There is so much of the story devoted to introspective images and thought processes, memories and dreams, that you will know our heroine Kabuki intimately and personally. The result is that we feel her pain, and know her mind, and therefore the storyline and the ongoing events of Circle of Blood hold meaning for us, the readers, and not just the people drawn on the pages. Now don't get me wrong. If you're looking for action, you've got it by the cold-blooded cutting edge fistfull, but if thats the ONLY thing you want, look elsewhere. Kabuki is both delicate and hard-edged. elegant and obscene. beautiful and bloody.
Nothing in Circle of Blood can be taken at its simplest, face-value. The imagery interlocks and relates throughout the whole story, and you will see how interwoven and complex every theme is. Even the title "Circle of Blood" holds incredible significance and many different meanings. Kabuki is Inexpressibly intriguing.
The first five volumes of Kabuki tell a story you will never forget, But Circle of Blood by itself, being the first part, is definitely complete, and it is individually the best of them all. Read it, and be amazed.