this book is unusual in that mr friedwald, who has obviously listened and studied his subjects recordings to an almost scholarly degree,is one of the very few music writers/critics whose writing is so engrossing that i want to go and buy all the artists recordings of those he reviews in the pages of this book and yet i find some of his sniping against rock music a wee bit tedious not so much that he does but he telegraphs his punches so when he initially attacks it it's ok but after awhile as you read thru' the book it becomes tedious and virtually blaming mitch miller and in particular elvis presley for the fall of western civilisation is again a bit tedious and over the top.his sniping at linda ronstadt i feel is also unfair because it was her records in the mid 80's that made me a fan of the american popular songbook,not so much her singing which i found not really up to the job but she did introduce a 16 yr old boy to those great songs and the wonderful nelson riddle and riddle actually made his first serious money from her records,he was only paid on a per chart basis for his classic work with frank sinatra as i understand it.his over the top praising of mel torme is too much,he was ok but no way deserving of the rapturous kudos handed out to his work by mr friedwald,he also seemed to ignore one my faves in lena horne,yet he wrote the liner notes to two of the best horne cds out there.flawed but i wouldn't be without this book and i would recommend it to anyone .