I loved "The Things They Carried" Short Story collection by O'Brien, so I decided to try this novel. I was skeptical at first because I am primarily interested in his fiction dealing with the Vietnam War, but this is a large part of "In the Lake of the Woods" Like some of his other writing, O'brien circles around and around events and actions, revealing more and more of what happened. I really liked the chapters of quotations from characters as if questioned by police along with quotations about John Wade and quotations relevant to the novel. O'Brien leaves it up to the reader to decide if Wade really did make his wife disappear or not with hypothetical chapters. It is a twist on on a mystery because it doesn't tie up all the loose ends and right away it is implied no one may ever really know the truth. I think this novel would make an excellent novel to read and discuss as a group or in a class. There is just so much to talk about. If you have never read anything by O'Brien this is a wonderful place to start. If you have read anything else by him, this will not disappoint.