As its tagline suggests, the FOR DUMMIES series is "a reference for the rest of us". Each introductory book has been designed to teach dilettantes as much as possible, in the shortest amount of time. A word of caution though, the FOR DUMMIES series is only `for dummies' in a relative sense. While the author, Ann Logue, laments the simplicity of the series, she also explains that Hedge Funds FOR DUMMIES is intended for an inquisitive, yet intelligent audience. The significance of this became increasingly apparent as I progressed further through this book.
Logue appears aptly qualified to author this text with more than 12 years experience as an investment analyst. Her qualifications include the Chartered Financial Analyst (CFA) certification and an MBA from the University of Chicago. In terms of her approach, she refreshingly engages the audience with a combination of colloquial wit and academic rigour. The only significant fault I could find is that she excessively repeats the basics, though this may be fitting for readers without a diverse investment background. Overall however, I believe Logue's unique style and objective opinions would make this book a worthwhile addition to any investor's collection.
The book begins with an ever-present question: what is a hedge fund? While the answer may be obvious to some, a lot of detail regarding the genesis and advancement of hedge funds is presented. One of the more interesting stories is that of a hedge fund operated by two of the US's most acclaimed and eminent finance professors; Robert Merton and Myron Scholes. Their fund profited from arbitrage trades in the bond market and ultimately collapsed due to a default on Russian treasury bonds. Was this collapse testament to the `random walk' of equity markets, or just the impropriety of the Russian Government? This is a question raised by only one of the many chronicles that Logue uses in her definition of hedge funds.
Prima facie, Logue's definition is more than adequate, but the early and repeated use of the term `investment partnership' piqued my curiosity. Worldly readers may know that while a partnership is a legitimate Australian business structure, it is more common as an American managed fund structure. The somewhat unfortunate implication of this is that the book is actually intended for an American readership. For Australian readers, this becomes increasingly obvious with US-specific discussions regarding taxation, superannuation, regulation and legal structure. Although this is confined to very few chapters, I did find myself skimming entire pages. However, all is not lost; this book still repeatedly surprises.
The major source of surprise is the depth of detail; this aspiring tome relinquishes its `introductory text' classification and rigorously investigates a range of investment topics (albeit in the context of hedge funds). The latter sections may begin with trivialities, such as the definition of alpha, but they promptly turn to challenge the reader by uniting academic theory, popular belief and the author's personal views. It was in these latter parts that I began to put the `for dummies' moniker into true context. Logue strives to `keep it simple', but at times she had me reaching for my university texts to revise Modern Portfolio Theory (MPT) and the Capital Asset Pricing Model (CAPM). I suggest that readers without a finance background at least engage a primer on managed funds (or mutual funds, as per the American lexicon).
As I became more comfortable with Logue's unique style and progressed further through the book, I found myself forgetting its American context and really enjoying the flow of information. After the formalities of defining a hedge fund, Logue presents a range of topics that get `under the hood' of these mysterious investment vehicles. One of Logue's more practical arguments discusses hedge funds as a unique asset class. She asks if we should place hedge funds in the same context as equities, fixed-income and property. In her true style, she presents the options, explains her opinion and then qualifies these with a discussion of Markowitz's portfolio theory. After this, the topics get quite technical for the layperson; ranging from the 11 possible ways to arbitrage equity markets, through to considering how hedge funds profit from the corporate lifecycle. Logue's constant quest to investigate all options while referring to academic theory kept me interested, even amongst unwanted references to US-specific details.
To answer whether this book achieves its purpose really depends on the locale of the reader. For the typical Australian investor, this book does not adequately educate on investment into local hedge funds. The funds in Australia are based on a different legal structure and must comply with dissimilar tax legislation and financial regulation. Despite this obvious downfall, the use of US-specific information is not nearly as ubiquitous as Logue's insightful annotations. While it does take some effort to decide what to dismiss and accept, my memories of this book are still described more by superlatives than shortcomings.
In summary, I sincerely enjoyed Hedge Funds FOR DUMMIES, especially its depth of content, the author's style, and her meticulous approach to forming arguments. Essentially, it is based on this experience that I recommend this book to budding investors worldwide.