It was actually quite amazing that this book was written in 1999, before Brokeback Moutain and a steady stream of gay romances published by people like Dreamspinner Press. And the novel hasn't aged at all. John Chapman comes across as a very well developed character with his sensitiveness and inner battles concerning his life and sexuality. Also Gwennie and Palmer were two strong characters, especially Gwennie with her idiosyncratic behaviour. Palmer was more of a modern free thinker, and the settlers partially conformed to the modern point of view of being ruthless and brutish. Nevertheless, the story was very engaging, thrilling and romantic, and the climax will keep you on the edge of your seat. But this is not simply a thriller or a romance, but the story of John Chapman, who has to deal with his traumatic past, his fears and his own identity. In this way this book is still as good as the better gay romances published today, but if you're looking for a even longer and more epic gay historical romance, I suggest strongly to have a look at Steph Minns' One Man Drowning.