Although I haven't been a big fan of David Nicolle's Medieval histories, which I generally find are erudite but don't pack a lot of military detail or analysis, his latest volume in Osprey's Campaign series, The Fall of English France 1449-53, is considerably different. This volume covers the final years of the Hundred Years War, where the French finally got their act together and eliminated the English footholds in Normandy and Gascony. While not as exciting as the big-pitched battles like Crecy or Agincourt, the operations in this phase of the conflict were fast-moving and more professional in many respects. The author puts considerable effort into teasing an unusual amount of military detail out of Medieval literary sources and is able to compile it into an interesting and coherent campaign narrative. Overall, The Fall of English France 1449-53 is a good campaign history and one of the author's best efforts in recent years.
The introductory sections are a bit brief - no section on opposing plans - but provide good background. The author highlights French efforts to reform and professionalize their army after decades of defeat, while English military resources were severely constrained by financial limitations. The French emphasis on standardizing and improving their artillery also paid dividends in the campaign. On the other hand, the author notes that the English armies devoted their resources toward fortifying their possessions, but fell behind in terms of tactics and technology. The campaign narrative is divided into two main sections: the fall (or liberation) of Normandy in 1449-50 and the fall of Gascony in 1451-53. The volume has one 3-D BEV map of the Battle of Formigny in 1450 and two of the Battle of Castillon in 1453. In both cases, the better led and organized French armies managed to defeat numerically-superior English forces. There are also numerous 2-D maps in the volume, which are generally helpful, but some are a bit too crowded. However, one item that is missing is a map of the siege of Bordeaux, which would have been helpful. Taken together, the text, maps and artwork by Graham Turner are effective in conveying the essential elements on these two campaigns. The author also provides a 2-page bibliography and a number of photographs of the terrain today.