I've lived in three New England states and traveled extensively. I'm always looking for new ideas, and we get lots of visitors so we keep a stack of guidebooks handy. Lonely Planet's New England Trips is one guidebook I won't be suggesting anyone take with them.
It's not just that the information is really uneven. Too many of the places mentioned aren't worth a detour to get to, and too many places worth a stop aren't mentioned. That's especially disappointing after the amazing places around the world that other Lonely Planet guides have taken me.
And it's not just that the information on any given attraction, restaurant or hotel is too brief to even figure out if it's someplace you want to go.
No, it's more than that. The idea of a book of "53 Themed Itineraries" with "1012 Local Places to See" turns out to be a really bad one. Maybe there are people who are interested visiting just sites related to "Pilgrims & Puritans" (Trip 16), and are willing to drive 269 miles just visiting sites on that theme. And who don't mind driving right past all kinds of fantastic places on the way ("No, Marge, we've already been through this, it's gotta be Pilgrims & Puritans, or we keep on driving ... "). Both of those people should probably buy this book. Everyone else should avoid it, because you really want to spend less time driving and more time sightseeing, eating, shopping or ... anything but deciphering guidebooks and driving.
Part of the problem is that 53 trips is way too many to try to cram into the book. They should have cut way down on the number of trips, and had more information about fewer itineraries. And created itineraries filled with really worthwhile stops, rather than the hodgepodge they ended up with to get to 53 and 1012.
They should also have expanded the arbitrary definitions of themed trips to explore one area more, and do it more effectively. (Really, even on the Vermont Ramble, it would be OK to drive the hundred yards across the river into New Hampshire to see some amazing things.) Follow this book and they'll have you circling New England for months, and driving thousands of miles.
Yes, thousands of miles. I did a quick tally of the mileage for their itineraries - about 8,000 miles. Sounds like good times, doesn't it?
Maybe this book is just meant to be for armchair travelers, dreaming about journeys they might take. Other than that, I'm not sure who they imagine would use and enjoy this book. First time visitors would get a bum steer from this book, and have to spend way too much time figuring out how to use it. Locals would have to comb through the book to find what they're looking for. Maybe it's meant as some kind of genius revenge on New Yorkers headed north ...