I'm going to have to part company with the rest of the reviewers on this one. While the author has an interesting voice alternating between the richly dark and the cleverly sardonic and the story concept is interesting, the execution was ultimately unsatisfying.
The beginning was compelling and remains the best part of the book. The emaciated and devastated bodies of two young women and their aunt are found in an unassuming Dublin home, under circumstances so shocking it makes the reader cringe but at the same time overwhelmed by curiosity. It's a near-flawless bit of foreshadowing that definitely set the mood - or would have.
The story then unfolds mostly via a journal written by one of the dead girls, and that's where it began to lose me. It never did recapture the feel of the well-done beginning, for me. I didn't care for the tone of the narrator Fiona, for one. It felt much too contrived. I didn't like any of the sisters, who all seemed rather directionless and dull. Most of all I thought the title character, the unbelievably (literally) handsome hottie around whom this story revolves, utterly banal. I couldn't help but think that the author (a man) had made the common mistake of many authors and decided to insert a secret fantasy version of himself into his writing. Maybe that's unfair, but that's just how it struck me. I couldn't relate to the way Fiona, Rosie, the aunt and every other female kept swooning over this rather irritating character who tells horrific fairy tale-type stories of torture and revenge. I found him a complete turn-off. I tried to just put that aside and accept the passion Fiona and the other women felt regardless of my own opinion, but I couldn't. I just couldn't relate, I suppose. I'm a woman, but I don't react that way to a man I've never met and I can't imagine doing so. Seduction on that level is cerebral, and it takes a little time - at least for most women. Or maybe that's just me! At any rate I think it was important that Jim be a well-fleshed character, and that was not accomplished by a long shot. He wasn't appealing, sexy, scary, or even interesting, and I found myself constantly wondering why this whole story centered around someone so dull.
I'd give it only one star except that it's obvious the author has talent. I'd like to see him use it a bit more creatively.