"The Valley of Fear" is one of four Sherlock Holmes novels ably adapted to graphic novel format by Ian Edginton and I.N.J. Culbard. Conan Doyle's short novel introduces Holmes' greatest nemisis, the brillant crime boss Professor Moriarty, while challengng the famous detective Sherlock Holmes and faithful sidekick Doctor Watson to solve a mysterious death at the country manor house of Birlstone.
As the story opens, Scotland Yard Inspector McDonald consults Holmes on a horrible murder. John Douglas of Birlstone Manor has been horribly murdered by the blast of a sawn-off shotgun at close range. There is no apparent motive and it is unclear who might be responsible. Holmes and Watson travel to Birlstone to interview the witnesses and examine the crime scene. Holmes quickly detects a deception; his solution will astonish the local police, Scotland Yard, and the reader.
Edginton has adapted all the essentials of the original novel into a 124-page graphic format, while Culbard's simple but evocative artwork brings Sherlock Holmes and Doctor Watson to life. As with two other of the novels, the story is presented in two parts, with Holmes and Watson solving a crime in the present, followed by an explanatory (and exciting) backstory to fill in the gaps. The backstory here concerns labor violence in a Pennsylvania coalfield, a gripping story in its own right. "The Valley of Fear" has been neglected in adaptions of Conan Doyle's stories to other mediums; Edginton and Culbard are to be congratulated for their nice job here. Highly recommended to Sherlock Holmes fans and to their children who need an introduction to the world famous detective.