A lost novel from Grand Master of Mystery, Donald E. Westlake, THE COMEDY IS FINISHED isn't so much a mystery novel as it is an survival story mixed with a little 1970s crime noire. Westlake originally wrote THE COMEDY IS FINISHED in the early 1980s, but he never had it published because he thought the overall plot structure of his novel was too similar to Martin Scorsese's 1983 movie THE KING OF COMEDY. Other than a comedian who is kidnapped, this novel doesn't share anything with THE KING OF COMEDY.
The setting of the story is Los Angeles, California circa 1975. Koo Davis is a famous comedian (ala Bob Hope), beloved around the nation for his films, USO tours, and television talk show. Koo is kidnapped by a group of five radicals who plan to use Koo as a tool in releasing other radical leaders from prison. The story moves back and forth between Koo and his experience with the radicals and the search and rescue operation for Davis led by a FBI agent who was somehow involved in the Watergate scandal.
There's lots of humor in the book as well as some serious introspection. Since it's not really a mystery, there's no puzzle to solve. Instead, the main plot of the story is whether or not Koo will live or die.
The only complaint I have about THE COMEDY IS FINISHED is that it feels a bit dated. It's not because of the setting, but more because of the overall tone and mood of the novel. The setting is the 1970s, but so are the tone and mood. There are references to events, such as the abduction of Patty Hearst, that many readers just won't understand at all. Also, the world has changed drastically since this book was first written. For example, we now live in a post-9/11 world and the type of the terrorists in the book almost seem quaint. Overall, though not a traditional Westlake novel, THE COMEDY IS FINISHED is a fitting final (?) novel from Westlake.