Okay, I can buy the talking animals -- willing suspension of disbelief and all that. But I do tend to think that Brown has gone a bit too far with some of the things the animals do. I found it fun, and I guess that if you except her premise that animals have human (or, as Brown says, above-human) intelligence, maybe you won't find this book so hard to swallow. It also lacks the closure of the other Mrs. Murphy mysteries, too -- Harry and friends never find out what really happened, although we, the readers, do.