In weniger als einer Minute können Sie mit dem Lesen von Bully Beef and Balderdash Some Myths of the AIF Examined... auf Ihrem Kindle beginnen. Sie haben noch keinen Kindle? Hier kaufen oder mit einer unserer kostenlosen Kindle Lese-Apps sofort zu lesen anfangen.

An Ihren Kindle oder ein anderes Gerät senden

 
 
 

Kostenlos testen

Jetzt kostenlos reinlesen

An Ihren Kindle oder ein anderes Gerät senden

Der Artikel ist in folgender Variante leider nicht verfügbar
Keine Abbildung vorhanden für
Farbe:
Keine Abbildung vorhanden
 

Bully Beef and Balderdash Some Myths of the AIF Examined and Debunked (English Edition) [Kindle Edition]

Graham Wilson

Kindle-Preis: EUR 9,02 Inkl. MwSt. und kostenloser drahtloser Lieferung über Amazon Whispernet

Kostenlose Kindle-Leseanwendung Jeder kann Kindle Bücher lesen  selbst ohne ein Kindle-Gerät  mit der KOSTENFREIEN Kindle App für Smartphones, Tablets und Computer.

Geben Sie Ihre E-Mail-Adresse oder Mobiltelefonnummer ein, um die kostenfreie App zu beziehen.


Produktbeschreibungen

Kurzbeschreibung

Was Beersheba the last great cavalry charge in history? Did the AIF storm the red light district of Cairo and burn it to the ground while fighting running battles with the military police? Was the AIF the only all-volunteer army of World War I? Graham Wilson’s Bully Beef and Balderdash shines a critical light on these and other well-known myths of the AIF in World War I, arguing that these spectacular legends simply serve to diminish the hard-won reputation of the AIF as a fighting force.

Wilson asserts that the story of the AIF is extraordinary in its own right, its fighting record so well established that there has never been a need to embellish that story. However, as Bully Beef demonstrates, the history of the AIF has become so shrouded in misinformation that what is now generally accepted as ‘history’ is often little more than myth and legend.

Did the men of the Light Horse shoot their horses rather than see them sold off to the hated ‘Gippos’? Was Alfred Gaby VC’s eerie studio portrait actually taken after his death? Did the AIF fight the war on an unrelieved diet of bully beef and
biscuits? Wilson painstakingly examines a number of myths associated with the AIF, some cherished and well seasoned others obscure and even whimsical.

With meticulous, at times forensic analysis, he sets out to debunk these myths,
using a range of first-hand accounts and official records to unravel the facts and set the historical record straight. Were Catholics in the AIF denied the VC because of their religion? Was Gallipoli an intelligence failure?

Graham Wilson mounts his own campaign to rehabilitate the historical reputation of the force free from hyperbole and jingoism to demonstrate that misleading and inaccurate embellishment does nothing but hide the true story of
Australia’s World War I fighting army.

Bully Beef and Balderdash deliberately targets some revered legends and, for those who cherish the mythical story of the AIF, this will be uncomfortable but essential reading. Yet, given the extraordinary truth of the AIF’s history, it is
certainly compelling reading.

Produktinformation

  • Format: Kindle Edition
  • Dateigröße: 7287 KB
  • Seitenzahl der Print-Ausgabe: 699 Seiten
  • Verlag: Big Sky Publishing (21. März 2012)
  • Verkauf durch: Amazon Media EU S.à r.l.
  • Sprache: Englisch
  • ASIN: B007NA9NHG
  • Text-to-Speech (Vorlesemodus): Aktiviert
  • X-Ray:
  • Word Wise: Aktiviert
  • Erweiterte Schriftfunktion: Nicht aktiviert

  •  Ist der Verkauf dieses Produkts für Sie nicht akzeptabel?

Mehr über den Autor

Entdecken Sie Bücher, lesen Sie über Autoren und mehr

Kundenrezensionen

Es gibt noch keine Kundenrezensionen auf Amazon.de
5 Sterne
4 Sterne
3 Sterne
2 Sterne
1 Sterne
Die hilfreichsten Kundenrezensionen auf Amazon.com (beta)
Amazon.com: 3.2 von 5 Sternen  6 Rezensionen
6 von 6 Kunden fanden die folgende Rezension hilfreich
5.0 von 5 Sternen A long-overdue corrective 27. Mai 2012
Von Morfydd - Veröffentlicht auf Amazon.com
Format:Kindle Edition
An excellent book, painstakingly researched and documented. I have always thought that the great achievements of the AIF speak for themselves and need no boastful, inaccurate boosting to receive the credit and respect due them. Especially pernicious has been the habit of Australian journalists and commentators in boosting Australian military successes by deprecating others, particularly British troops, or ignoring them completely,(the French and almost every other Allied force in the Great War).
Graham Wilson demolishes such myths as;Australians natural aptitude for soldiering, the cult of the bushman-soldier, propagated by Charles Bean, historian of Australia in WW1, the AIF as the sole volunteer force and the Light Horse at Beersheba making the last cavalry charge.
In particular, the leading role of British and French(among others) contingents at Gallipoli is described.
While doing so, no disrespect is intended or shown, but the AIF'S position as,inevitably, a small part of the British Empire forces,5 out of almost 60 divisions, and a total Allied strength of around 200 divisions on the Western Front, is put into perspective. Inexperience and a non-militaristic outlook and tradition meant that the AIF had to experience the learning curve common to all forces from a British style social and political background. That the AIF achieved what they did is all the more to their credit, without any need of the exaggerated myths and excessive claims made on their behalf, by jingoistic journalists and historians.
We also need an author who will highlight the proportion of United Kingdom-born and first generation English, Scots, Irish and Welsh volunteers in the 1ST AIF, if only to show how spurious are the distinctions often drawn,in a particularly boastful way, between Australian and British troops in the first world war.
Respect is due to all troops who helped defeat aggressive and militaristic Germany in 1918, whatever their country of origin, while of course honoring those from this country, who heeded the call, and sacrificed much, but as ordinary men at arms, not as mythological heroes.
3.0 von 5 Sternen Military buffs will be challenged 21. Januar 2013
Von Greenfingers - Veröffentlicht auf Amazon.com
Format:Kindle Edition|Verifizierter Kauf
This will really have you challenging your opinions of the effecacy of our early military encounters. The book is meticulously researched, even to the point of tedium at times with vast lists of the units in battle and how many did this or that. I was gob-smacked at the tenacity of the aurthor. I bet he does not get invited to too many RSL nights. Anyhow a good read for any ex-service guys and gals. Cheers Greenfingers
4.0 von 5 Sternen Interesting 17. November 2012
Von Jetpack - Veröffentlicht auf Amazon.com
Format:Kindle Edition|Verifizierter Kauf
The author lays out a ton of myths about the Australians in WWI, under the premise that they don't need them, and provides tons of information. It's a bit overwhelming, but interesting stuff. I didn't know that Newfoundland had their own troops in WWI.
1 von 2 Kunden fanden die folgende Rezension hilfreich
1.0 von 5 Sternen lost interest 6. November 2012
Von ilbob - Veröffentlicht auf Amazon.com
Format:Kindle Edition|Verifizierter Kauf
I got this for free a few weeks ago because it sounded interesting. I read 14% and just couldn't take it anymore.

History does not have to be boring, in fact, it is often fascinating, but this book (at least the part I read) just was unable to keep my interest. I had hoped for a telling of the story and a contrast between the truth and the mythology, but the author never really got there.

It purports to refute a number of myths regarding the Australian forces that served in WWI. I lost interest after scanning through page after page of lists of units and types of jobs the recruits held prior to joining. To me those kind of things belong in an appendix where it does not mess with the story.

Then it claimed the Boston tea party was mostly a myth as it was really about smugglers being mad at the tax on tea being reduced. While there is actually some truth to that, the author lost a lot of credibility with me by flat out suggesting that was the primary reason. It was a complicated situation that cannot be dismissed so easily.

The author seems to have some kind of point he is trying to make, but he beats around the bush so much trying to make the point that I lost interest.

So, as is my practice with books I start and just don't have the interest in finishing, it gets one star.
4.0 von 5 Sternen Four Stars 17. Juli 2014
Von Errol - Veröffentlicht auf Amazon.com
Format:Kindle Edition|Verifizierter Kauf
Not recommended reading for propaganda sections of the the Aussie media.
Waren diese Rezensionen hilfreich?   Wir wollen von Ihnen hören.

Kunden diskutieren

Das Forum zu diesem Produkt
Diskussion Antworten Jüngster Beitrag
Noch keine Diskussionen

Fragen stellen, Meinungen austauschen, Einblicke gewinnen
Neue Diskussion starten
Thema:
Erster Beitrag:
Eingabe des Log-ins
 

Kundendiskussionen durchsuchen
Alle Amazon-Diskussionen durchsuchen
   


Ähnliche Artikel finden